Edinburgh A beat Glasgow A at Scotstoun

27 Nov 2023

Edinburgh A took a deserved win on the road in Glasgow last Friday, scoring four tries in a full blooded affair to win 27-26

Ben Muncaster bragged a brace of tries, with Charlie Shiel and Heriot’s Rugby back Liam Richman also on the scoresheet.

The Edinburgh A squad was made up of Edinburgh senior and academy players, plus additions from the FOSROC Super Series, and put the men from the west to the sword in an abrasive encounter behind closed doors at Scotstoun Stadium.

Glasgow hit the front with a maul try, before Charlie Shiel responded with a score of his own, breaking free from the base of a maul to dot down. Richman put the visitors ahead with a stunning score; Cammy Scott chipped out wide to Heriot’s winger Lewis Wells, who offloaded to the onrushing Richman to score in the corner.

The home side hit back early in the second half, however Ben Muncaster’s decisive scores put the capital men in control. The first try was a well crafted team try, all started with an excellent break from fullback Harry Paterson. The rangy 15 broke free, releasing Muncaster who exchanged passes with Richman to go under the sticks.

Muncaster’s second score came from a clever individual move. With pressure mounting on the opposition’s line, Muncaster broke through a ruck undetected to cross the whitewash.

Glasgow hit back with two scores to put them a point behind, however Edinburgh held out to take the win, with Cammy Scott excellently bundling Amena Caqusau into touch with the clock in the red.

Edinburgh ‘A’ Squad

15. Harry Paterson 14. Finn Douglas 13. Liam Richman* 12. Grant Hughes* 11. Lewis Wells* 10. Cammy Scott 9. Charlie Shiel 1. Robin Hislop 2. Adam McBurney 3. D’Arcy Rae 4. Jamie Campbell 5. Jamie Hodgson (C) 6. Wallace Nelson* 7. Freddy Douglas 8. Ben Muncaster

Replacements: 16. Paddy Harrison 17. Robbie Deans 18. Luan de Bruin 19. Euan McVie 20. Jerry Blyth-Lafferty 21. Finn Burgess 22. Marcus Holden+ 23. George Barber*

* Heriot’s Rugby
+ Stirling Wolves

RELATED

Hospitality & Events Women in Business: Networking Event Mon 9 Feb 2026 Scotland Men U20 Academy stars shine as Scotland U20 triumph in Treviso Mon 9 Feb 2026 Camps & Events Record-breaking Evolution Festival lights up Hive Stadium Fri 6 Feb 2026 Player of the Month Vote now: January Scottish Building Society Player of the Month Thu 5 Feb 2026 Scotland Men Schoeman, Ashman and Gilchrist start to power Scotland pack Thu 5 Feb 2026 Club News Edinburgh Rugby confirms initial phase of performance staff changes Wed 4 Feb 2026 Scotland Men Edinburgh stars set for Scotland A clash Wed 4 Feb 2026 Scotland Men U20 Ten selected for U20 Six Nations opener Wed 4 Feb 2026 Celtic Challenge Late rally not enough as Brython Thunder strike at Hive Stadium Mon 2 Feb 2026 URC Leinster surge in second-half to overcome gritty Edinburgh Sat 31 Jan 2026 Inclusivity & Outreach “I love it” – Kelso’s Allison Whitson to deliver match ball at Thunder clash Sat 31 Jan 2026 Schools & Grassroots Evolution Festival set to kick-off Celtic Challenge clash Fri 30 Jan 2026 Cruikshank names new-look backline for Brython test Fri 30 Jan 2026 URC Edinburgh side named for Leinster test Fri 30 Jan 2026 Scotland Men U20 Wolfenden named captain for Scotland U20 Six Nations campaign Thu 29 Jan 2026 URC Lawrie calls for brutal honesty as Edinburgh prepare for Aviva Test Wed 28 Jan 2026 Hive Stadium to host inaugural Celtic Challenge Final Wed 28 Jan 2026 Focus turns to Brython Thunder as Edinburgh Women look to bounce back Mon 26 Jan 2026 Young Edinburgh side fall to clinical Gwalia Lightning Sun 25 Jan 2026 Inclusivity & Outreach Four decades of ‘The Blues’: Heather Bonnar honoured as Community Hero Sat 24 Jan 2026